The Facade of Federalist Incongruity: A Political Pretense To A Popular Menace

  • Miss. Sasi Varadharajan School of Excellence in Law, Chennai, TN
Keywords: Sand mining, Environment, Hydrology, Sand inflow, Mining lease, Environmental clearance


Sand, being a minor mineral, slips out of the Union List of the Seventh Schedule; which section 15 of the MMDR Act[1] re-assures. This, coupled with entries 23 and 64 of State List is construed as categorical constraint on Union interference in the popular menace of sand mining. But, this paper here crusades to construct an inclusive interpretation of entries 17A, 17B, 20, 34 of concurrent List and entries 13, 42, 51, 54, 56, 97 of the Union List to compel unconditional compliance to conservation justice principles. Sand mining, apart from being viewed as a robbery of a resource in itself, must be viewed under the wide lens of wildlife, habitation and ecology. These three are intertwined in a way that the changes in the geomorphology of river, its physical and chemical properties, the consequential head-cutting thereof erode the exotic wildlife of their naturally available habitat, migrating the zoonotic diseases along with them to human settlements. The artificial lateral erosion in the form of degrading dredging also attacks the stability of standing structures like bridges, water tanks, railway pillars, etc. The human habitation is also affected by the suspended particulate matter in air and potholed pathways, a result of wrongly chosen routes for transport. Hence, as lucrative and necessary the business of sand and construction sounds, it is more crucial to consider the grave existential threat of rampaging our rivers. The State specific solutions have either been stuck in 1950s laws[2] or come off as late epiphanies to altogether ban mining. A combined crusade for preservation and public health commands a quasi federalist conscience of a common conservation law than a duty dividing federalist approach between the Centre and the States.[1] Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957.[2] An example would be the Tamil Nadu Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1959.


1. Mathias Kondolf .G, 'Hungry Water: Effects of Dams and Gravel Mining on River Channels' (1997), Environmental Management (Springer), 21, 533-551.
2. Binoy Aliyas Mattamana , Shiney Varghese and Kichu Paul, 'River Sand Inflow Assessment and Optimal Sand Mining Policy Development' (2013), International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering, 3, 306.
3. Ministry of Mines, 'Sand Mining Framework' (2018), Government of India, 63-122.
4. Manu Moudgil, 'Impacts of Sand Mining on Ecosystem' (2018), India Water Portal.
5. Gireesh Chandra Prasad, 'Kerala struggles to rein in the river that changed course' (2019), Live Mint.
6. 'Uncontrolled Sand mining and Kerala floods' (2018), Straitgate Action Group.
7. Prof.Podila Sankara Pitchaiah, 'Impacts of Sand Mining on Environment - A Review' (2017), SSRG International Journal of Geo Informatics and Geological Science, 4.
8. Sasi .V, 'Sand Mining in Tamil Nadu - Conflicting Realities' (2017), Indian Journal of Natural Resources, Energy and Environmental Law, 2.
9. Putra Rizal Ichsan Syah, Purnaweni, Hartuti, 'Land Use and River Degradation Impact of Sand and Gravel Mining' (2018), E3S Web of Conferences, 31, 09034.
10. Bindhusri .A, Arunachalam .M, 'Environmental Impact of Sand Mining in Tamiraparani river, South Tamilnadu (2015), International Conference on Engineering Trends and Science & Humanities, 123- 132.
11. Kondolf G.M., Smeltzer M., Kimball .L, 'Freshwater Gravel Mining and Dredging Issues' (2002), White paper prepared for Washington Departments of Fish and Wildlife, Ecology and Transportation, 122.
12. Kondolf G.M., 'Geomorphic and Environmental Effects of In-stream Sediment Mining' (1994), Landscape Urban Plan, 225-243.
13. Marius Dan Gavriletea, 'Environmental Impacts of Sand Exploitation - Analysis of Sand Market' (2017), Sustainability, 9, 1118.
14. Chandrasekhara Rao M., 'Sand Mining : Depletion of Groundwater in Papagani Catchment' (2006), Economic and Political Weekly (EPW), 41.
How to Cite
Varadharajan, M. S. (2020). The Facade of Federalist Incongruity: A Political Pretense To A Popular Menace. GLS Law Journal , 2(1), 21 - 30. Retrieved from