Determining the Status and Treatment of “GIG-Workers” under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
Abstract
The gig economy, characterized by short-term contracts, freelance work, and on-demand tasks, has witnessed rapid growth in recent years, reshaping the way people work and earn a living. India is the fifth-largest country in terms of gig-workers. Gig workers offer a cost-effective solution, often working on a project basis, reducing continuous payroll expenses. Moreover, the gig economy facilitates market expansion and job opportunities, making it accessible to students, retirees, stay-at-home parents, and those seeking additional income. They may thus have a different type of job, but their significance is equal to that of a regular employee. Although this new work paradigm gives workers flexibility and possibilities, it also raises serious questions regarding the rights and protections afforded to gig workers.
Due to the nature of the work, they are perceived as “second class workers” and denied social security benefits that come with formalised employment. Unfortunately, the law is yet to catch up with this fast-paced economy. Existing Indian labour laws fail to recognise Gig workers under its organised labour legislation i.e., the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. They are clubbed with unorganised labourers and are thus deprived of all the benefits given to a traditional employee; all benefits that are rightfully due to them. Gig workers are now an essential component of the contemporary economy, adding to its flexibility and dynamism. Governments, corporations, and society as a whole must address the difficulties that gig workers encounter and provide a framework that protects their rights and well-being while allowing them to benefit from their invaluable contributions as the economy grows. The former half of this paper highlights the social issues around their employment and legislative lacunae in their recognition. The latter half comparatively analyses the international position to propose additional tests to be adopted in India. Lastly, it explains the challenges that could be faced in bringing a change to the current system and the way forward from there.
References
Kiran Singh, “An Analysis Of The Gig Economy In India”, (The Amicus Curie, 11 Sept 2022)
Nilanjan Banik, “All Is Not Well with India’s Gig Economy” (The Wire, 9 May 2022) )
India Staffing Federation, ISF Annual Report (2022)
Shreeya Thakur, “What Is Gig Economy: Understanding The Meaning, Factors, Types And More!” (UnStop, 13 Oct 2022) < https://unstop.com/blog/what-is-gig-economy> Assessed on 17 October, 2023
Tabassum Sultana. J , “Gig Economy And Laws Protecting Gig Economy In India’s Gig Economy/Gig Worker”, (2014) 2 (1) JLRJS 562
Andrew Harley, “Cambridge Dictionaries Online” (Cambridge University Press, 1999)
The Code on Social Security 2020, s. 2(35)
The Code on Social Security 2020, s. 2(60)
Vinay Aravind, “Swiggy strike is a reminder that service aggregators care little for workers’ rights” (Newslaundry, 2 Sept 2020) < https://www.newslaundry.com/2020/09/02/swiggy-strike-is-a-reminder-that-service-aggregators-care-little-for-workers-rights> Assessed on 17 October, 2023
Subir Bikas Mitra & Piyali Ghosh, “Engaging Contract Labour: Learnings from Landmark Judgements”, [2021] 47 (1) XLRI 1
Suneera Tandon , Varsha Bansal, “The loneliness of a delivery man” (Mint, 18 Sep 2019)
Id.
Radhika Chitkara, Vikas Kumar, “"Behind the veil of algorithms: Invisible workers" -A Report on Workers in the ‘Gig’ Economy” (PUDR, 15 Dec 2021) < https://www.pudr.org/release-pudrs-report-behind-veil-algorithms-invisible-workers-report-workers-gig-economy> Assessed on 17 October, 2023
Harsh Upadhyay, “Coming Monday Ola and Uber drivers to go on strike in Mumbai, NCR and Bengaluru, demand commitment of Rs 1.25 lakh business” ( EnTrackr, 15 March 2018)
Aditi Mishra and Suyog Ghosh Dasttidar, “Navigating the Challenges of the Gig Economy: A Legal Analysis of Protection to Gig Workers in India and Overseas” (2021) 6(1) IJLMH 2183
Tyagi, Akanksha, “GIG Economy and Its Impact On India. ” (2018) 4 (7) IJETSR 18
Ministry of Commerce and Industry, India’s Booming Gig and Platform Economy, NITI Aayog, (Policy Brief 2022) Pg 3
Unorganised Workers’ Social Security Act 2008, s. 2(m)
Minimum Wages Act 1948
Payment of Wages Act 1936
Employees' State Insurance Act 1948
Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act 1952
S C Srivastava, Industrial and Labour Laws (5th edn. Vikas Publishing House, 2007) 167
Industrial Disputes Act 1947, s. 2 (j)
Industrial Disputes Act 1947, s. 2(s)
Chintaman Rao v. State of Madhya Pradesh AIR (1958) SC 358
Tata Consultancy Services v. State of AP (2004) 271 ITR 401
Bangalore Water Supply vs A. Rajappa & Others AIR 1978 SC 553
John Joseph Khokar v. Bhadange B. S. & Ors. 1998 (1) LLJ 447 (Bom);
Larsen & Toubro Ltd. vs. Employees' State Insurance Corporation W.P. Nos. 22960 of 2007
Ranjit Kumar Mondal vs State & Ors W.P. 16209(W) of 2018
Industrial Disputes Act 1947, s. 2 (j)
S C Srivastava, Industrial and Labour Laws, (5th edn. Vikas Publishing House, 2007) 167
Id.
Management of Safdarjung Hospital v. Kuldip Singh Sethi AIR 1970 SC 1407
Kirloskar Brothers Ltd. v. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Delhi and Anr., 1977 (34) FLR 206
Industrial Disputes Act 1947, ch 5A, 5B
Sudeep Sudhakaran , Tanvi Malpani, “Not Fancy Tags, Gig Workers Need Legal Rights and Protections” (NewsClick, 8 Aug 2023) < https://www.newsclick.in/not-fancy-tags-gig-workers-need-legal-rights-and-protections> Assessed on 17 October, 2023
Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act 1970
Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act 1970, S. 20.
Secretary, Haryana State Electricity Board vs. Suresh & Others 1993(3) SSC 601
Hussainbai Alath vs Factory Thozhilali Union 1978 I LLJ 397
Yogesh.M, Tr. Kalai Lakshmi, “a study on the challenges faced by gig economy workers in Indian facility management industry with special reference to Chennai city” (2022) 10 (5) IJCRT 834
Ram Singh and Ors. v. Union Territory, Chandigarh and Ors 2004(1) BLJR 490
Workmen of Nilgiri Cooperative Marketing Society v State of Tamil Nadu (2004) 3 SCC 514
Dharangadhara Chemical Works v. Management AIR 1957 SC 264
Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd. v. Mahendra Prasad Jakhmola 2019 (2) LLJ 1
Avtar Singh Harpreet Kaur, Introduction to Labour and Industrial Law (3rd edn. LexisNexis, 2014) 521
Balwant Rai Saluja & Another vs. Air India Ltd. & Others] (2014 ) 9 SCC 407
Food Corporation of India v. Jagdish Balaram Bahira (2017) 8 SCC 670
Prachi Agnihotri v. Urbanclap Technologies India Private Limited, 2021 SCC OnLine CCI 18
Aditi Mishra and Suyog Ghosh Dasttidar, “Navigating the Challenges of the Gig Economy: A Legal Analysis of Protection to Gig Workers in India and Overseas” (2021) 6(1) IJLMH 2183
Himanshu Kumar Vidyarthi v. State of Bihar 1997 4 SCC 391
Haldia Refinery Canteen Employees Union and Ors. v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. and Ors. AIR 2005 SC 2412.
‘Steel Authority of India Ltd. & Others vs. National Union Water Front Workers & Others (2001) 7 SCC 1
Air India Statutory Corporation vs. United Labour Union’ 1997 LLR 305 (SC)
Uber BV v Aslam (2021) UKSC 5
California Assembly Bill 5 (AB5) 2019
Dynamex Operations West Inc. v. Superior Court of Los Angeles 4 Cal.5th 903
EU Directive 2019/1152 2019
Prakhar Dubey, “Gig & Platform Workers: A Way Towards Formal Labour Recognition”, (2022) 1(2) SLSNMLR 58
Federation of Dutch Trade Unions (FNV) v. Uber ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:5029
Anthony Deutsch and Toby Sterling , “Uber drivers are employees, not contractors, says Dutch court” (Reuters, 13 Sept 2022)
Id.
R C Sharma, Industrial Relations and Labour Legislation (Eastern Economy edn. PHI learning, 2016) 365
Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Dept. of Industrial Relations 48 Cal. 3d 341 (1989)
S C Srivastava, Industrial and Labour Laws (5th edn. Vikas Publishing House, 2007) 167
Lawson v. Grubhub, Inc. 302 F. Supp. 3d 1071
Air Line Pilots Association, Int'l, Petitioner, v. Federal Express Corporation, Respondent 32 F.3d 1079
S C Srivastava, Industrial and Labour Laws, (5th edn. Vikas Publishing House, 2007) 167
Ramar Veluchamy, ‘A Study on Work Life Integration of GIG Workers’(eds. 1), An Anthology of Multi-functional perspectives in Business and Management Research (Eureka Publications 2021)
S C Srivastava, Industrial and Labour Laws, (5th edn. Vikas Publishing House, 2007) 167
Vijeta Banwari, “Gig Economy: Challenges and Opportunities in India”, (2018) 5(11) JETIR 413
The Code on Social Security 2020
Industrial Relations Code 2020, s. 2(zr)
Industrial Relations Code 2020, ch. 3
Aditi Mishra and Suyog Ghosh Dasttidar, “Navigating the Challenges of the Gig Economy: A Legal Analysis of Protection to Gig Workers in India and Overseas” (2021) 6(1) IJLMH 2183
Suresh Chand Aggarwal, “The Status of Self-employed, Contract, and Gig Workers in India: Some Recent Changes”, (2022) IARIW 1
Yeong Gug Kim, Yeasun Kate Chung & Eunju Woo, “Gig Workers’ Quality of Life (QoL) and Psychological Well-Being in Service Delivery Platform” (2023) 15(11) Sustainability 8679
Deepika M G, Madhusoodhan M, “Labour Laws for Gig Workers in the Context of Labour Law Reforms” (2022) 57 (30) EPW < https://www.epw.in/journal/2022/30/perspectives/labour-laws-gig-workers-context-labour-law-reforms.html> Assessed on 17 October, 2023